Editor’s note: This article is one of an occasional series profiling the 12 finalists for the Milwaukee Awards for Neighborhood Development Innovation (MANDIs). The Mitchell Street Library/Alexander Lofts is a finalist for the State Farm Building Blocks Award for a real estate project that advances the community.
You can vote today for People’s Choice Award winners. Click here to vote.
Sirena Hernandez, 21, went to the old Forest Home Library, 1432 W. Forest Home Ave., almost every day when she was in elementary school. She did her homework there, played games on the computers and socialized with friends.
On a recent Thursday morning, Sirena sat with her mother, Candida Hernandez, at a table rigged with six brand-new laptop computers at the new Milwaukee Public Library Mitchell Street Branch, which replaced Forest Home last fall. Her brother, Marcelo, 15, and 3-year-old son Noah were also with them. As a family, they just recently started coming to the library again.
“I notice that, now that we’ve been coming, he loves reading,” said Sirena of Noah.
The mixed-use development was completed over the course of a highly publicized process that included community meetings at the space where the library is currently housed. Sixty market-rate apartments fill the floors above, and an old cold storage building in back. It is the neighborhood’s first apartment development in the last 40 years that is not income-restricted.
The building, located at 906 W. Historic Mitchell St., was built in the early 1900s and has served as a department store, hardware store and, in the ‘80s, included a punk rock nightclub. Most recently it housed the Hunger Task Force, the state and county probation office, and a Social Security office and unemployment center.
The library, located on the building’s ground floor, boasts historic railings, columns and a marble floor intermixed with computer stations, a bilingual catalogue, numerous charging outlets and free wireless internet. The hope was that the state-of-the-art library space and upscale apartments would provide “a significant economic impact” to the surrounding area, according to developer Gorman & Company’s Wisconsin Market President Ted Matkom.
Gorman also operates in Arizona, Florida, Colorado and Illinois.
The census tract in which the development is located is one of Milwaukee’s youngest, with a median age of just over 24. It is also one of the city’s poorest. The area’s median household income of $22,591 is less than half of the median income in Milwaukee County. Forty-six percent of residents and 62 percent of children live in poverty.
Ald. Jose Perez called the project “a home run,” and “the envy of a lot of my colleagues.”
“It’s been part of what I consider the renaissance [of] Mitchell Street,” he said.
Nancy Bush, director of Historic Mitchell Street Business Improvement District #4, added, “We had this dark building at night; now we’ve got light, we see people coming and going — kids, teens, parents with their families. This particular project, in the 10 years I’ve been here, is the best thing that has happened to our commercial corridor.”
“I haven’t had a library card in years,” said Candida Hernandez, 41, as she uses a computer to search for jobs. Hernandez, who has worked as a cashier, housekeeper and waitress, has been unemployed for about a year. Hernandez lives near 21st and National with her mother. “It is real hard,” she added.
Wenona Lee Gardner, who lives blocks from the newly opened library, called it, “a lifeblood.” Gardner said she lives on about $575 a month in disability benefits, sharing a one-bedroom apartment to lower her living costs.
Gardner is highly engaged in the community. She leads weekly workshops on “The Artist’s Way” — a book she got from the library — and recently launched her own business. She is also taking online classes in media design, which she wouldn’t be able to without the internet access the library provides.
The project would never have happened without the 60 apartments, which were used to close a funding gap of $5 million, according to Matkom. A one-bedroom unit in The Alexander Lofts costs at least $995 a month and a two-bedroom goes for a minimum of $1,225. According to Matkom, other area one-bedrooms — market rate or rent-restricted — go for $550 a month, and a typical two-bedroom rents for $650.
“By leveraging the public library as this amazing public asset … we could attract higher incomes to this severely distressed neighborhood and charge people rents that are double what were currently in the neighborhood,” Matkom said. The apartments are expected to bring people with higher incomes to the retail corridor, which will benefit businesses along Mitchell Street, according to the development company.
Tomeitha Moore, 50, a resident of the lofts, moved to the building because of the convenience and amenities, including a workout room, community room and more, she said. Moore works for the Wisconsin Department of Corrections.
Moore, who lives with her partner, a teacher, called the apartments “affordable for those who are working.” She believes both the Alexander’s higher-income residents and nearby businesses, which she described as having “very reasonable” prices, will benefit from the new development.
Gardner said it’s “always a concern” that at some point she may not be able to afford to live in the neighborhood where she grew up. Just recently, her Medicare costs increased and her monthly food stamp allotment was reduced by about half.
Sixteen percent of housing units in the census tract are unoccupied, twice the rate of Milwaukee County. The lofts are already 90 percent full, according to Matkom.
Wenona Lee Gardner says
Thank you JABRIL FARAJ for publishing my comments in this article! I wanted to share that I teach Artist’s Way courses on Saturdays 3-5 pm at the Mitchell Library. We reserved the conference room on the second floor so feel free to join us! The Artist’s Way Circle is hosting a Pizza Party for the Artist’s Way Circle members at Transfer Pizzeria and Cafe tonight Thursday February 1, 2018 at 7:30 pm during LIVE MUSIC!
Also I am actually a New Media Journalism Masters of Fine Arts Student with Full Sail University. I texted you and I was interested in interviewing you to learn about your career as a Milwaukee reporter.
Also you left out the most important news! I am running for President 2020!!! I am a Native American Christian Witch and Bisexual supporting LGBTQIA. I am the first Mohican Indian Woman from Milwaukee running for President!
Again thank you for interviewing me.
Wenona Lee Gardner
Wenona Lee Gardner says
Also I want to point out The Artist’s Way Circle is online at Facebook.com/groups/artistwaycircle So join us online for some Artist’s Way fun!
Wenona Lee Gardner
Mary Ann Borman, ED, Management Development Consulants says
Locating a library on Mitchell St was a brilliant idea. There was no other library in the area accessible to the children and adults who can now use their comprehensive resources. I was brought up on the Southside and had to ride the streetcar on So. 13th St downtown every weekend to the main library and museum when I was nine and all through high school after going through the entire children’s reading section at the Lincoln Library. Community safety issues would make that prohibitive for community childen now, plus the high cost of busfare. I had noted while working on the Southside that there really were no similar library opportunities for the children growing up in recent years in the area. (I had my first job at the Mitchell St Penneys, store in highschool and worked for years at UMOS in the building just across the Street.) I loved the area and was so sad to see some of the mainstays of the street close: Kunzelman Esser, Goldmans and other businesses. I know the library will draw the children and parents in the community. Although the addition of the apartments are a great idea, they certainly are not medium priced, and definitely are not affordable for most of the current residents of the area. I am concerned that they will draw higher income renters similar to the Bay View area with the changes that follow. Higher end income tenants will want higher end nearby neighborhood resources eventually driving out the current moderate priced restaurants, stores and other neighborhood mainstays of the current residents, consequently causing higher rents and more expensive living costs and resources. With this type of neighborhood resurgence, we will also see the prices of other businesses catering to higher-end clients rising beyond the means of the current local residents as well. With Milwaukee’s current homelessness rate, I am concerned that we may drive out the very people we are trying to assist in the community. Moderate rate apartments would have been a better solution, with funding sought from foundations and other community resources to keep up the maintenance cost of the building.