Allegations of price gouging at El Rey led to a sharp rebuttal from the store’s representatives. (Photo by Edgar Mendez)
Editor’s note: This story has been updated to clarify that William Horst is not the owner of the Golden Chicken restaurant located at 3032 S 13th St. despite a claim he made on Facebook. Barry Bloom says he’s owned the restaurant for nearly two years.
Ground beef, chicken fajita meat, tilapia fillets and avocados were on sale this week at El Rey, Milwaukee’s oldest and largest Hispanic grocery store chain. But it was a 24 pack of 23-ounce Nature’s Crystal bottled waters selling for $19.99 that had some patrons crying foul over the weekend.
In a Facebook post shared hundreds of times, but now removed, shoppers accused the iconic company of overpricing items in high demand because of COVID-19, the new coronavirus disease.
“I thought price gouging was illegal in WI?” read one post. “They’re taking advantage of the community and the situation,” read another.
Others also accused the store of overpricing other sought after items such as bleach.
This photo taken at El Rey over the weekend sparked accusations of price gouging. (Screenshot from Facebook)
William Horst, who said he owns Golden Chicken, 3032 S. 13th St., went even farther.
“We should boycott El Rey $10 for bleach $20 for case of water, burn that place down,” he wrote in a Facebook post. Horst could not immediately be reached for comment, but according to subsequent social media posts, he later apologized.
However, Barry Bloom says he’s owned the restaurant for nearly two years, adding: “As the current owner, I want to make it clear that the former owner’s comments do not reflect in any way the opinion or feelings of me or my co-workers,” Bloom told NNS. “Rather, we choose to remain positive and try to be good neighbors and members of the community, wishing and hoping the same for our city, state and country during this challenging time.”
The social media criticism drew a quick response from Olivia Villareal, the wife and business partner of El Rey co-founder and owner, Ernesto Villareal.
“It has come to mine and Ernesto’s attention that our name, EL REY, is being dragged through the mud,” she wrote Saturday in a Facebook post shared more than 435 times.
She explained that the water bottles were meant to be sold individually for 89 cents, adding an employee took it upon himself to package it together for $19.99. Villareal also mentioned that El Rey had a 24 pack of water for $4.99 but that it had already sold out.
Store issues statement
El Rey, which first opened 42 years ago on what is now S. Cesar E. Chavez Drive by Ernesto Villareal and his brother Heriberto, issued a statement addressing the controversy Sunday.
“I can assure you that increasing margins in this time of need is not on El Rey’s agenda at any location . . . We have desperately tried to keep our shelves stocked as much as possible this week for you and are actively searching for many everyday products that our normal suppliers are out of stock,” the store said in a statement. “It has become apparent that the costs on these items have and will be volatile. We will continue to search for the best deals we can and provide the cheapest prices we are capable of.”
The company has four stores and a tortilla factory in Milwaukee.
Many have jumped to the defense of El Rey, which has long been a major philanthropic supporter in the city.
“El Rey is the only grocery store who has provided free dinner for Hip Hop Chess Club of Wisconsin … This company has a place in our community, and it is not like them to take, they give,” read one post.
“We love El Rey’s and the family! Thank you for all you do for our community,” read another.
Others added that prices at El Rey on specific items, including cleaning supplies, are typically on the high side, and that they don’t think the store is gouging customers. At the El Rey store on Cesar E. Chavez Drive on Monday morning, the price on a 3.57-liter bottle of Clorox bleach was $6.99, while at Walmart the same bottle retails for $4.14.
Concerns of overpricing
Concerns over price gouging continue to grow across the country as shoppers report shelves empty of products such as toilet paper and hand sanitizer.
A Wisconsin law against price gouging went into effect for the first time in history when Gov. Tony Evers declared a public health emergency on March 12.
Ti Gauger, public information officer for the Wisconsin Department of Agriculture, Trade and Consumer Protection, said her department had received eight complaints about price gouging before last week’s emergency declaration and has gotten 11 more since.
Information on the number of complaints filed in Milwaukee or whether anyone had filed a complaint against El Rey are not yet available.
According to a statement on the Wisconsin Department of Agriculture, Trade, and Consumer Protection website, during a public health emergency, state law prohibits ”wholesale and retail sellers from increasing prices of consumer goods and services by more than 15%.”
That threshold is determined by the highest price within the market area during the 60-day period before the emergency was declared.
‘Challenging time’
Consumers can report possible cases of price gouging or scams related to COVID-19 by contacting the department’s consumer protection hotline at DATCPHotline@wisconsin.gov, calling (800) 422-7128 or by filing an online complaint.
Peter Skopec, director of the Madison-based consumer advocacy group, WISPIRG, said despite the measures in place in Wisconsin , that doesn’t mean prices on certain items won’t be higher than normal.
“Not all price increases are price gouging,” he said. “Sometimes retailers have to increase prices in unusual situations like this, for example when they have to pay more for the goods themselves or shipping becomes more difficult.”
Still, he added, “This is a challenging time for many people, and unfortunately, there are some individuals and companies out there who want to take advantage of that fear and uncertainty.”
Other resources
The Better Business Bureau offers these tips for consumers and businesses.
Edgar is a senior staff reporter for the Milwaukee Neighborhood News Service. Mendez is a proud graduate of UW-Milwaukee, where he double majored in Journalism and Sociology, and of Marquette University, where he earned a master’s degree in Communication. As an accomplished journalist, Edgar’s awards include a 2018 Regional Edward R. Murrow award, several press club awards and a Society of Professional Journalists’ regional award for columns dealing with issues such as poverty, homelessness and racism.
A very fair Article.
I just wish others would examine the facts before jumping to conclusions.
The person mentioned in this article never apologized that I am aware of and he was visited by Police today which probably prompted his forced apology.
I encourage all consumers to check prices this week especially as many of our competitors in the area are dropping or giving less specials that Hispanics depend on .
Also would like to make sure people know that Clorox does not sell us their products at the same price as wall mart and big box stores .
They could care less about a mom a pop corner stores when it comes to selling us products at the same price .
Regarding the premium water . Are people going at stores that sell packages of core water & smart waters ? Then have people claim they should sell for 3-4 dollars ?
Crazy
Gracias, papa Ernesto. We appreciate you and your family for giving back to our community.
All the Asian store needs to stop gouging prices on rice, the prices are too high
I can assure you that there are VERY few grocery stores or ANY businesses in Milwaukee who do as much WITH and for the community as El Rey. This was an honest mistake and should be the least of our community’s worries.