Critics of decision to close Ascension St. Francis Birthing Center continue protests | Milwaukee Neighborhood News Service
Devin Blake
January 6, 2023
After Ascension Wisconsin provided a fuller explanation this week about its decision to close the Ascension St. Francis Hospital Birthing Center, critics continue to voice their displeasure.
In a statement to local media on Wednesday, an Ascension Wisconsin spokesperson called the closure of the birthing center  “a clinical decision.”
“Ascension St. Francis Hospital is no longer able to provide birthing services due to a combination of the loss of our obstetrical providers and low birthing volumes,” the spokesperson said.
“While we have had two providers delivering babies at Ascension St. Francis, one physician recently departed our system and the other announced retirement effective at the end of December 2022,” the spokesperson said.
Do you have feedback on Milwaukee NNS's reporting? Take our survey to let us know how we're doing!
But critics continue to stress the ways in which the closure creates serious barriers to adequate medical care for South Side residents, many of whom are immigrant Spanish-speakers, Latino and other people of color.
Jamie Lucas, executive director of Wisconsin Federation of Nurses & Health Professionals, or WFNHP, the union that represents staff at St. Francis, takes issue with the spokesperson’s statements about the number of providers and the rate of births.
“For years, we’ve had conversations with them about meaningfully pursuing other providers to work out of the hospital, to keep services afloat. This goes years back,” he said. “They just let it go through attrition and didn’t fill positions …. .”
He added that he was informed of some providers who were interested in working there in the past but who were not offered competitive salaries.
And the rate of birth at St. Francis goes “hand in hand” with the issue of number of providers, he said.
According to data provided by Ascension Wisconsin, birthrates declined far more rapidly at St. Francis than at the two other Ascension locations now closest to the South Side: Ascension Columbia St. Mary’s Hospital and Ascension SE Wisconsin Hospital, St. Joseph Campus.
The difference in decline shows that the dwindling numbers of births at St. Francis is “not organic,” said Lucas. “If there aren’t multiple providers there, you’re not going to have high numbers of births. They suppressed the number of providers … so the numbers obviously dropped.”
According to Ascension, since 2017, the rate of births at St. Mary’s declined roughly 14%; at St. Joseph’s, the rate declined roughly 33%; and at St. Francis, the rate declined roughly 48%.
According to state data, birthrates generally have been falling. In 2010, there were 12 births per 1,000 in population. In 2020, that had dropped to 10.4 per 1,000.
A few days after the initial announcement of the closure, WHFNP held a demonstration at Milwaukee City Hall. Demonstrators held another rally Wednesday – this time outside the home of Bernie Sherry, ministry market executive of Ascension Wisconsin.
According to Ascension’s website, Sherry has “led the integration of Ascension Wisconsin’s four legacy health systems to provide one integrated faith-based healthcare system.”
Organizers stated the reason for the location of the rally was to highlight the financial reasons they believe are the actual reason for the closure. They contend these reasons prioritize the pockets of a few executives over the clinical needs of patients.
“Since 2016, Ascension has slowly dismantled St. Francis Hospital. But we will not let them place profit over patients,” Connie Smith, president of WHFNP, said during the rally. “Bernie Sherry, you had your hands in this.”
According to the statement from Ascension Wisconsin, it intends to direct those in need of birthing and labor services to other Ascension locations, especially the St. Mary’s campus.
This plan, however, ignores similar staffing problems at St. Mary’s, said Tracey Schwerdtfeger, steward of WFNHP Local 5000, the chapter representing St. Francis employees. “We’re not seeing that upper management truly cares about the staffing crisis – that is not only happening at St. Francis but all their other facilities. … St. Mary’s is a great example. … That unit is understaffed, too, so for them (Ascension Wisconsin) to say they are concerned about understaffing … it just doesn’t make any sense.”
Both St. Mary’s and St. Joseph’s are roughly 15 to 20 minutes by car from the South Side. This distance does not take into account the barriers to care, like transportation, on the South Side, said Lucas. These locations would be a lengthy bus ride for those who depend on public transportation.
Ascension Wisconsin has created an environment in which patients must now “travel outside of their community” to get services– a largely “Latino, immigrant and brown-skinned community,”  Smith said.
After the rally, Lucas and Schwerdtfeger expressed their belief that this is a problem that can be fixed.  “We believe that Ascension has the resources to be able to reopen,” Schwerdtfeger said.
But Alderwoman JoCasta Zamarripa, of the 8 District, expressed skepticism after the rally.
“I had hoped that maybe we could try to advocate, but I did speak with Ascension’s leadership once – I didn’t find them willing to move. Even to hold off on the decision. That was very disheartening,” she said.
Ascension Wisconsin declined to go on the record and for attribution responding to specific allegations by WFNHP or its other critics about its closure explanation.
For those who need to contact potential providers, St. Mary’s unit is located at 2323 N. Lake Drive. The number is 414-585-1000
The unit at the St. Joseph campus is located at 5000 W. Chambers St. The number is 414-447-2000.
The Aurora Women’s Pavilion at Aurora West Allis Medical Center is located at 8905 W Lincoln Ave. The number is 414-328-6000.
The CARE Network of Wisconsin, an organization that provides childbearing education and resources relating to doulas, labor assistants and midwives, can be contacted via its website or Facebook page.