Milwaukee Public Schools still does not have a list of schools it plans to close or made final decisions on other plans to help address declining enrollment and its budget deficit.

At the final scheduled Great Schools Committee meeting on Monday community members reviewed the variety of ideas administration, staff and community members have proposed throughout the course of the meetings, which began in September.

Advertisement

The district listed ideas for each of the eight school board districts on walls across the North Division High School cafeteria. Attendees marked their favorite ideas with blue dots and least favorite with red dots.

MPS Superintendent Brenda Cassellius formed the Great Schools Committee to help set criteria for potential school closures. 

She said the district will review all feedback and post it online alongside the Budget Advisory Committee’s budget priorities, and open public comment for 30 days.

Cassellius said the district will also do specialized outreach at impacted schools, following a push from the Milwaukee Inner-City Congregations Allied for Hope’s Education Task Force to make sure all affected communities receive adequate notice and discussion about closures, mergers and investments at their schools.

Fix what’s there

The most popular ideas centered on fixing or replacing aging buildings. 

At the Nov. 9 Great Schools Committee meeting, Siefert School Principal Deirdre Lafford suggested rebuilding her school on the playground site while students go to school in the old building. Last night, attendees also supported adding a new HVAC system and elevators at Siefert, which was built in 1903.

Expanding Rufus King High School was one of the most popular ideas at the meeting. (Photo by Alex Klaus / Milwaukee Neighborhood News Service / Report for America)
A resident leaves her feedback on an investment suggestion at the MPS Great Schools Committee meeting at North Division High School on Monday, Nov. 16. (Photo by Alex Klaus / Milwaukee Neighborhood News Service / Report for America)

A building addition at Rufus King High School garnered the most support of any idea. 

Angela Harris, an MPS educator and parent of a Rufus King student, said the school needs an updated athletic field and equipment.

Among the attendees, fifteen people backed rebuilding Lincoln Avenue School to serve more than its own students. MPS is in discussions to potentially rebuild the school, which was destroyed in a June fire and will be demolished in the coming months. 

Community members from District 4 on the North Side pushed for a new building behind Auer Avenue School, despite planning firm Perkins Eastman’s including the school in January among its recommendations of  five schools to close. A suggestion to add 3-year-old kindergarten classes and seventh and eighth grade received 12 blue and five red dots.

Closures and mergers draw the most pushback 

Attendees met most suggestions to close or merge schools with disagreement.

Closing Riley Dual Language Montessori School was not a popular idea at the Great Schools Committee meeting on Monday, Nov. 16. (Photo by Alex Klaus / Milwaukee Neighborhood News Service / Report for America)
MTEA Executive Director Amy Mizialko and MICAH Education Task Force Chair Deborah Way-Selinas review suggestions at North Division High School on Monday, Nov. 16. (Photo by Alex Klaus / Milwaukee Neighborhood News Service / Report for America)

Closing Riley Dual Language Montessori School and moving the dual language program to another school was one of the least popular ideas, with 19 red dots.

Nine participants disagreed with an idea to close the 10 smallest schools in the district, while two supported the idea. Seven opposed an idea to merge Carver Academy and Cass Street School.

A dozen people opposed a proposal to merge several schools at once: Moving Milwaukee School of Languages into the Marshall High School building, merging Marshall into Obama School, Vincent High School and James Madison High School, merging Kilbourn School into Kluge Elementary School, and Hampton School into Lancaster School. 

Several closure ideas in District 3 were shared for feedback – Franklin School, which is under capacity by almost 300 students; LaFollette School, which is under capacity by more than 200 students with only 14% of students living in the area; Sherman Multicultural Arts School, which is  under capacity by more than 500 students with $2 million in deferred maintenance costs; and Townsend Street School with declining enrollment and over $5 million in deferred maintenance. 

One attendee wrote that they’d agree with the closures, but only if they are spread out over 10 years and come with new buildings.

Demand for Montessori, but expand carefully

Milwaukee Public Schools operates the largest cluster of public Montessori schools in the country, according to the district. Students in Montessori schools stay with the same teacher for three years and learn in a different style than traditional schools.

Participants wanted to see expansions to the Montessori program and greater investments into the existing schools. 

One participant said most Montessori schools are full, signaling these programs are popular and the district should create more seats. Another three people supported turning Pratt Elementary School into a Montessori school. 

If MPS expands its public Montessori program, one participant said it’s important the district does so carefully. Montessori teachers require specialized training, and they want to see principals specialized in Montessori learning as well.

Community schools and transportation

Throughout Great Schools Committee meetings, attendees like Joshua Taylor, MPS paraprofessional and an organizer with the Milwaukee Party for Socialism and Liberation, have called for the district to expand its Community School Program. 

A resident reviews a post-it note at the Great Schools Committee meeting at North Division High School on Monday, Nov. 16. Alex Klaus / Milwaukee Neighborhood News Service / Report for America

“Expanding the Community School Program, strengthening our community support, sustaining school cultures,” Taylor said in October. “Closing schools, especially in District 4, doesn’t do any of those things.”

Attendees also said they want to see greater developments of the Community School Program at Hopkins Lloyd Community School, another school originally on Perkins Eastman’s suggested closure list in January. Others want to see a Community School Program at Auer Avenue School.

Several attendees supported the creation of a system of community schools to serve students with adverse childhood experiences.

Across districts, people called for a shuttle system to help neighborhood students with long walks get to school. In the Nov. 9 meeting, participants said requiring students to walk a mile to school is a barrier. 

One suggested a shuttle should leave every 15 minutes to drop off students. Another suggested shuttling kids who live farther than three blocks away from the school.

‘We deserve middle schools’

Several participants want the district to end its K-8 model, or create more middle schools. 

Several attendees pushed the district to end the K-8 program in MPS at the Great Schools Committee meeting on Monday, Nov. 16. (Photo by Alex Klaus / Milwaukee Neighborhood News Service / Report for America)

Seven people supported changing Obama, which currently serves 5-year-old kindergarten through 12th grade, to serve only high school or only 3-year-old kindergarten to 6th grade. Two people left red dots.

One person noted that the K-8 environment is “not appropriate for 11 and 12 year olds or the 3-year-olds.”

“Stop pushing sixth graders back into elementary schools,” another note read. “We deserve middle schools.”


Alex Klaus is the education solutions reporter for the Milwaukee Neighborhood News Service and a corps member of Report for America, a national service program that places journalists in local newsrooms to report on under-covered issues and communities. Report for America plays no role in editorial decisions in the NNS newsroom.


Jonathan Aguilar is a visual journalist at Milwaukee Neighborhood News Service who is supported through a partnership between CatchLight Local and Report for America.

Creative Commons License

Republish our articles for free, online or in print, under a Creative Commons license.

Alex Klaus covers education and is a Report for America corps member. Previously, she covered Detroit K-12 schools for Chalkbeat Detroit. She’s also reported for Outlier Media, Detroit Documenters and Bridge Detroit as a freelancer. She graduated from Wayne State University with a degree in urban studies and public history.